Link: http://libproxy.umflint.edu:2060/pqdweb?index=2&did=1402797151&SrchMode=2&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1257221367&clientId=16043
Terrence Terrell Dawson
James Schirmer
November 3, 2009
Part Two: Pop-Up Scholarship
I chose this article to use for the Pop-Up Scholarship assignment because I love poetry and would like to be a published author in my future. Poetry is very important. It is important because it is a way of sharing your opinion but more critically and creatively than just saying how you feel; it’s a deeper process than just opening your mouth. I chose to write on Paul Laurence Dunbar because his poetry is very old and he has a huge variation of critics and these who accept his work, some, like me, do both.
In all, this article is beautifully written. I wouldn’t change much of the wording, but some of what’s said is not proven true without citations and I believe the author missed out on doing that. I believe the information provided however is very true and highly connected to his work as a poet and his lifestyle during his time as a poet. The transitions from poem to poem and paragraph to paragraph are of excellent quality. The author provides useful information with dates to show the reasons for why Dunbar would run off in “La La Land” with his vocabulary sometimes. Truthfully, there is nothing that can be said that can’t be proven with a little more evidence from personal knowledge or through more credible reliable scholarly journals or biographies.
The things I truly disliked about this article were that the author is repetitive in more ways than one. Right off the back this is easy to be seen by simply reading the Abstract and the first paragraph of the article. No real article should have word for word exact vocabulary in both the abstract and the first paragraph of the article. Now, if the author would have used information from all of the paragraphs to formulate an abstract as it should have been done, this wouldn’t have been noticed or seemed so repetitive throughout the piece. The first time reading the piece through, it scared me to see the similarities in the first paragraph and the abstract because it made me think the author knew nothing about Paul Laurence Dunbar. However, after reading the piece over carefully for the second time, I see that that previous statement is an understatement. Everyone would agree with me if they took the time to read this article through twice, one time quickly and another slowly correcting the errors they see.
I also noticed the author of this scholarly journal loves long ass sentences. I have no problem with that, literally I don’t. The issue I have however is that where the sentences are long as hell, there is lots of juicy meat waiting to be discovered but it’s brushed under the rug because too much non-sense is said in the same sentence embellishing the point trying to be made.
Another case of bad variation is when the author decides to give their opinion. Throughout the piece the opinion is mostly listed at the opening of the article. That is not what we want to do here. The reason we don’t want to do this at the beginning is because if I know nothing about Paul Laurence Dunbar and I come across al of these opinions from the get go, I will believe the author has nothing to say and is full of b.s. with no real purpose to actually write the piece in the first place.
What I disliked probably the most was when the author decided to use jargon expecting others to know what the hell that she is talking about. Nobody know what you mean, sweetie and it would be so much better if you explained what you were trying to say if you are going to use it in the first place, else wise what you have to say is purposeless and utterly useless.
The author also tends to point out that Paul Laurence Dunbar was an alcoholic. Ok, so what’s your point and where is your proof. Just because you say this in your paper more than once does not make you a creditable sources to say someone is an alcoholic. In fact there is lost of negative things said in this article which is not proven with a source but said repetitively, that does not mean you have made them true.
There are also plenty of times I actually say, “Give me an example” on this article. Give me an example is the last thing you should want to hear because the piece is very lengthy and is very informative but you can’t prove anything you’re saying. If I was a scholarly journal reviewer, I would probably walk away from this piece more than five times before I actually read it through because not having examples hurt me so.
Now in my closing note to the article, I mentioned that if I was a teacher grading this work I would most likely give a “B-“ because of the not having citations, not enough examples, and in some places not enough critical thinking and that I recommend having someone else to look at the article. Overall, I was very critical and humorous in the piece until I was forced to get hysterical and become a hard-ass because of lack of necessary information. I didn’t have any concern in providing any more information than what was there and what I asked for because this is the authors work not mine, they should know what the should say. I had an interest with playing with the text at first but then I said this is too much to have to shoot for correcting text alone so I let it go and found other expectations not being followed. I did this because the text is not as important as how and when you say relevant things in your work. If you don’t speak up and out you will miss good reviews and good readers wanting to read your work.
I can't believe two of us in the same class did our pop-up assignments on the same person: I also did my pop-up scholarship on Paul Laurence Dunbar and several of his poems. Next to Edgar Allan Poe, he is one of my favorite poets, and his triumphs over the difficulties of segregation in his time are to be admired.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read your actual Pop Up comments yet, so I can't respond to those. However, I'm quite appreciative of this particular post as it clearly elucidates your approach to the assignment and also offers some in-depth reflection on your unique process. After reading your words here, I'm all the more interested in reading your Pop Up comments.
ReplyDelete